High Speed Rail Authority accused of skewing numbers
SACRAMENTO, CA (KFSN) -- The controversial high speed rail project to link Northern and Southern California got slapped with a lawsuit on Thursday. It was a legal attack that Menlo Park and Atherton were all too eager to join. The lawsuit claims that proponents of the plan to bring the train through the Peninsula, gamed the numbers.
The latest lawsuit against the California High Speed Rail project claims the ridership numbers are rigged.
Those projections were used to decide one of the most contentious segments of the 800-mile system: the Pacheco Pass from the Central Valley to the Bay Area or the Altamont Pass, which crosses over to the Bay Area further north.
Ultimately, the High Speed Rail Authority chose the Pacheco Pass.
"Our expert has concluded that the model was jimmied essentially, so as to come out with higher ridership for Pacheco than it should have," says David Schonbrunn from the Transportation Solutions Defense & Education Fund.
The plaintiffs say they used the High Speed Rail Authority's own forecasts and on a per capita basis, the numbers don't seem right.
They says a Merced resident would ride the bullet train more than 20 times a year, a Gilroy resident would ride it more than 17 times a year, while a Los Angeles resident, would barely use it once a year.
"They rigged the model so extremely, in my view, that they screwed up the LA numbers," says Rich Tolmach from the California Rail Foundation.
The High Speed Rail Authority says it never skewed numbers.
In fact, the method used to project ridership was praised last month by a leading trade journal for being "robust and accurate."
"There was no attempt to try to build preference through ridership in any fashion," says Curt Pringle, the High Speed Rail Authority chairman.
Lawsuits could prevent California from meeting important deadlines. Because federal stimulus money is partially funding this project, the state must break ground by September of 2012.
Any portion of the $43 billion project still tied up in lawsuits by then will likely miss out on that first round of funding.
high speed rail, politics, nannette miranda
- Group finds 'structurally deficient' bridges in Valley 9 min ago
- Stabbing victim well known in the Tower District 8 min ago
- Fire truck overturns in collision in SE Fresno 4 min ago
- Man arrested for death of baby girl at LNAS
- Dentist sentenced for son's dentist chair overdose 27 min ago
- Fresno's bike lane battle continues 51 min ago
- Lawmakers want to restore dental care to Medi-Cal
- Hotels helping displaced guests after Oakhurst Lodge fire
- Brad Pitt face blindness
- Clovis standoff ends peacefully, suspect in custody
- Top Valley grad rises from humble roots
- Three shot, two dead in Merced shooting
- Costco plans new store in Hanford
- Arrest made in Pinedale arson fires
- Fresno's bike lane battle continues
41 min ago
Most Viewed StoriesMost Viewed VideoMost Viewed Photos