Does the majority have the right to take rights?
SAN FRANCISCO -- A three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals began hearing arguments on the constitutionality of Prop 8, the voter-approved California initiative outlawing gay marriage.
Proponents of Prop 8 are seeking to overturn a ruling by Federal Judge Vaughn Walker that held that the initiative is invalid under the federal constitution. In Judge Walker's opinion, it violates the equal protection clause. Proponents say that the people, those who voted to pass the initiative, should not have their will tossed aside by one "activist judge."
No matter how the panel rules, this issue can conceivably continue for another year and a half, as the losing party will have the option of appealing to the full 9th Circuit Court of Appeals and ultimately, the U.S. Supreme Court.
Question of the Day: Should the majority by initiative have the right to take rights away from the minority by referendum?
- Child thrown from apartment fire in Hayward 8 min ago
- Albertsons parent Cerberus to buy Safeway
- Peninsula cold case murders linked to Reno killing
- 7 On Your Side: The dark side of green lighting
- Two injured in two-alarm fire in San Jose 12 min ago
- Senate blocks change to military sex assault cases
- Oakland mayor to deliver State of the City address
- Oakland teen accused in AC Transit fire in court
- Batkid was scheduled to appear at Oscars
- Bryan Stow attackers charged with federal crimes
- Some have privacy concerns with wearable technology
- Wheel of Fortune is coming to Northern California!
- roundup: Nob Hill gas leak; Scam warning
- weather: Bay Area weather forecast for Friday
Most Viewed StoriesMost Viewed Photos