Obama faces tough Democratic tax cut sell
WASHINGTON (AP) - December 8, 2010 -- In a role reversal, President Barack Obama now has to lobby fellow Democrats to vote for a bill he considers crucial - legislation that would retain existing tax rates for the middle class and stretch the safety net for the jobless.
House Democratic leaders say the package is tilted too much in favor of the wealthy, putting Obama on the defensive for striking a deal that is picking up support among GOP lawmakers and business groups.
Some Democrats are unhappy that Obama agreed to extend expiring tax cuts to all Americans, including high earners, and that he agreed to impose a lower estate tax on wealthy heirs. Both provisions are seen by many Democrats as giveaways to the rich that will do little to help the economy.
In return, Democrats would get extended jobless benefits for people who have been unemployed for long stretches. Workers would also see their share of Social Security payroll taxes cut by nearly a third for the coming year.
"So far, the response has not been very good," House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said. She called the estate tax provision "a bridge too far."
If Democrats kill the package, it would mark a stunning defeat for Obama and a huge political bet that voters will blame Republicans as much as Democrats for an impasse that would lead to higher taxes starting Jan. 1. Many congressional insiders doubt that Democrats will take that gamble. But liberal lawmakers' discontent is hard to measure in the wake of last month's big election setbacks.
Senior White House adviser David Axelrod said Wednesday he believes disenchanted Democrats will decide to vote for the package when they realize how angy voters will be "if they wake up on Jan. 1" with a substantial tax increase, roughly $3,000 a year for a typical family.
He said Obama had no choice but to accede to Republican demands for continuing existing rates for the wealthy in order to spare higher rates for the middle-class. He also said the president was forced to make concessions to protect the jobless.
"We're not going to play Russian roulette with the lives of the American people, with all the millions of people that are going to lose their unemployment insurance right n ow without this bill going forward," Axelrod said in an interview on ABC's "Good Morning America."
In an interview on NBC's "Today" show, he said it would be "borderline immoral" to allow taxes to go up in the midst of economic hard times.
Obama went on national television Tuesday to say that compromise is necessary to prevent a massive tax increase that would hit taxpayers at every income level and to prevent millions of unemployed workers from losing jobless benefits.
"This country was founded on compromise," the president said.
Despite their minority status, Senate Republicans last week blocked Obama's long-promised bid to end Bush-era tax cuts for households earning more than $250,000. Republicans insisted that all the tax cuts be extended, for rich and poor alike.
"I have not been able to budge them," Obama said at the televised news conference. Without a compromise, he said, 2 million unemployed people "may not be able to pay their bills, and tens of millions of people who are struggling right now are suddenly going to see their paychecks smaller" because of income tax increases.
"I'm not here to play games with the American people or the health of the economy," he said.
Under the proposal cutting back Social Security payroll taxes, workers would pay a 4.2 percent tax rate instead of 6.2 percent - a $120 billion tax cut for workers, starting on Jan. 1.
Households making between $40,000 and $50,000 would get an average tax cut of $810 next year, according to an analysis by the Tax Policy Center, a Washington research group. Households making between $100,000 and $200,000 would get an average tax cut of $2,162.
The package would continue other programs such as enhanced tuition tax credits and tax breaks for businesses that hire new workers. It would impose a 35 percent federal estate tax, but each spouse could exempt up to $5 million from taxation.
Under current law, the estate tax, which was repealed for 2010, is scheduled to return next year with a top rate of 55 percent.
Officials said that, overall, the proposal could increase federal borrowing by $900 billion.
The lower estate tax has emerged as the biggest sticking point among House Democrats.
"That's the topper," said Rep. Bill Pascrell Jr., D-N.J. "I understand give and take. But I have to resolve in my mind if this was too much giving."
Rep. Anthony Weiner, D-N.Y., said, "I don't think that the president should count on Democratic votes to get this deal passed."
Republicans and business groups have been generally supportive of the package.
Senate GOP leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky said he expects "a large majority" of Senate Republicans to support the package.
Both the Business Roundtable and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce - two business groups that have been at odds with the president's economic policies - praised the package.
"Enacting this bipartisan framework forged by the president and Congress is one of the best steps Washington can take to eliminate the uncertainty that is preventing our employers from hiring, investing and growing their businesses," said Bruce Josten, the chamber's vice president for government affairs.
taxes, president barack obama, u.s. house of representatives, u.s. senate, washington, d.c., republicans, democrats, inside politics
- Hit and run victim found near Wilmington road 19 min ago
- Periods of rain today, getting cooler 1 min ago
- WATCH: Action News Online
- 2013 Troop Greetings
- Would-be robber stabbed; suspect's mom talks
- Funeral for Nelson Mandela to be held Dec. 15th 9 min ago
- Photos: Nelson Mandela: Through the years
- Video: Jim Gardner recalls visiting Mandela's cell
- Center City rape victim speaks to Action News
- Police question suspect in Christmas package theft 2 min ago
- Reward offered after dogs found in trash bags
- Charges filed in alleged chop shop raid in N. Phila. 3 min ago
- Feds accused of targeting minorities in stash house stings
- 2 women hospitalized after Schuylkill Expy. crash
- Hit and run victim found near Wilmington road
19 min ago
- Police question suspect in Christmas...
2 min ago